Fitbit Alternatives: Five Trackers and Watches Compared
Five devices compared on listed price and whether each needs a subscription.
The five Fitbit alternatives on this page are the Withings ScanWatch Light, Polar Loop, Apple Watch SE 3, Amazfit and Oura Ring. Each one is compared on its listed price, whether it requires a subscription and the features its vendor publishes.
Google's Fitbit page states that the Fitbit app is now the Google Health app. Its paid tier, Google Health Premium, starts at $9.99 a month and includes personalized coaching built with Gemini, Google's artificial intelligence (AI) model.
The Fitbit Charge 6 serves as the reference device on this page. Its listing includes built-in global positioning system (GPS), an electrocardiogram (ECG) app for heart rhythm assessment and blood oxygen saturation (SpO2) tracking.
Prices appear as each vendor lists them. Where a vendor shows no figure, the text says so.
Fitbit Alternatives at a Glance
| Product | Billing unit and entry price | Best fit |
|---|---|---|
| Fitbit Charge 6 | $129.95, down from $159.95; Black Friday deal saves $30, ends 12/02; or four payments of $32.49. Includes 3 months of Google Health Premium | Pick if you want built-in GPS, an ECG app, Google Maps turn-by-turn directions and Google Wallet tap to pay on the wrist |
| Withings ScanWatch Light | $249.95; optional Withings+ from $9.95 a month, first month free for new subscribers | Pick if you want a hybrid health watch with up to 35 days of battery life |
| Polar Loop | $169.99, shown against a listed $199.99 in a Black Weeks sale; wristband variants listed at +$29.99 and +$49.99 | Pick if you want a screen-free band with no subscription |
| Apple Watch SE 3 | From $229; Black Friday promotion gives a $50 Apple Gift Card with purchase | Pick if you already use an iPhone and want Crash Detection and Fall Detection |
| Amazfit | Bip 6 $79.99; Active 2 $114.99 (was $149.99); Helio Strap $99.99 | Pick Bip 6 for the lowest listed hardware price here; Helio Strap for a screen-free band with no required subscription |
| Oura Ring | Oura Ring 5 has $100 off in a Black Friday sale that ends Nov. 30; membership $5.99 a month or $69.99 a year in the US, first month free for new members | Pick if you want Oura Advisor, the AI-powered health companion, included with membership, and an Android 11+ or iOS 16+ phone |
Are you one of these vendors? Update your listing
How the Fitbit Alternatives Differ
The five alternatives differ on three things their vendors state: the hardware price, whether a subscription is required and which health features the device includes. Among the devices with a hardware price, the Amazfit Bip 6 at $79.99 is the lowest and the Withings ScanWatch Light at $249.95 is the highest. The Apple Watch SE 3 starts at $229. Oura Ring 5 is on sale for $100 off through Nov. 30, but Oura's pages do not show a ring list price, so Oura is not ranked on hardware cost.
Subscriptions are one point of difference. The Polar Loop and the Amazfit Helio Strap list no required subscription. Withings+ is optional from $9.95 a month, and Oura's membership costs $5.99 a month or $69.99 a year. Apple's Apple Watch SE 3 page does not mention a subscription.
The devices also differ in their displays. The Polar Loop and Helio Strap are screen-free. The Amazfit Bip 6 and Active 2 both have active-matrix organic light-emitting diode (AMOLED) displays. Withings and Oura do not describe a display on the pages used here, so there is no display comparison for them.
Battery life is stated in different units. The Withings ScanWatch Light lists up to 35 days, the Bip 6 up to 14 days, and the Active 2 and Helio Strap up to 10 days each. Apple lists 18 hours with fast charging. Oura's pages give no confirmed battery figure. The Fitbit Charge 6 and Polar Loop pages do not state battery life.
Want to be added to this alternatives page?
Contact usWithings ScanWatch Light
Withings lists the ScanWatch Light at $249.95 and calls it a hybrid health watch. It gives up to 35 days of battery life, the highest battery figure among the alternatives on this page. It also names an algorithm, HealthSense4, but Withings does not say what that algorithm measures.
Other ScanWatch models on the same page cost $369.95 and $499.95. Withings+ is an optional subscription that starts at $9.95 a month, and the first month is free for new subscribers. Withings says the subscription adds clinical expert care, scores such as Readiness and a Health Assistant. Withings also says its data is free without the subscription and that Withings+ 'enhances your free data.'
The subscription arithmetic is simple. Twelve monthly payments of $9.95 come to $119.40, while the annual price of $99.50 saves $19.90. Hardware at $249.95 plus one year of the annual plan totals $349.45. The listing also offers 1 month of Withings+ free with every purchase.
Pick the ScanWatch Light if you want a hybrid watch with the highest battery figure in this comparison. Withings says the subscription is optional, and its data is free without it.
Polar Loop
Polar describes the Loop as a screen-free, subscription-free fitness band. Its listing says it tracks heart rate, sleep and daily activity 24/7. The price shown is $169.99, against a listed $199.99 during a Black Weeks sale.
Wristband options cost extra. Polar shows variants at +$29.99 and +$49.99. Adding the $29.99 variant to the base price gives $199.98, and adding the $49.99 variant gives $219.98. Polar does not state battery life.
At its shown price, the Loop costs $40.04 more than the Fitbit Charge 6 at $129.95. Polar does not mention GPS, an ECG app or contactless payment, all of which Fitbit lists for the Charge 6. Pick the Loop if you want heart rate, sleep and activity tracking with no screen and no subscription.
Apple Watch SE 3
Apple lists the Apple Watch SE 3 from $229. Its listing gives 18 hours of battery life with fast charging, water resistance to 50 meters and GPS. Crash Detection and Fall Detection are included, along with Sleep Score and overnight vitals.
Apple says the watch works with iPhone and needs one, so you cannot use it with an Android phone. Apple's Black Friday promotion gives a $50 Apple Gift Card with purchase of an Apple Watch SE 3. If the card is counted at face value against the $229 starting price, the net cost is $179.
The starting price is $99.05 above the Fitbit Charge 6's $129.95. Fitbit lists an ECG app for the Charge 6, and Apple's Apple Watch SE 3 page does not mention one.
Pick the Apple Watch SE 3 if you already use an iPhone and want Crash Detection and Fall Detection on the wrist. Its 18-hour battery figure is shorter than the day counts listed for the Withings and Amazfit devices.
Amazfit
Amazfit's US listing shows three products: the Bip 6 at $79.99, the Active 2 at $114.99 (was $149.99) and the Helio Strap at $99.99. The Bip 6 has the lowest listed hardware price in this comparison. The Active 2 price is $35.00 below its earlier price.
The Bip 6 has an AMOLED display, up to 14 days of battery life, 140+ workout modes including smart strength training, and AI coaching. The Active 2 has a 1.75-inch AMOLED display, sapphire glass, 160+ workout modes and up to 10 days of battery life. The Helio Strap also lists up to 10 days.
Both watches list a free Zepp app; the Bip 6 listing adds health and food tracking. The Helio Strap is screen-free and lists no required subscription. At $99.99, it costs $70.00 less than the Polar Loop's $169.99 price.
Pick the Bip 6 if the lowest listed price matters most. Pick the Active 2 if sapphire glass, 160+ workout modes and a 1.75-inch display matter more than the Bip 6's longer battery figure. Pick the Helio Strap if you want a screen-free band with no required subscription.
Oura Ring
Oura sets its membership at $5.99 a month or $69.99 a year in the US, with the first month free for new members. Oura's membership, home and rings pages show no ring list price, so no ring-plus-membership total is given. Oura Ring 5 has $100 off in a Black Friday sale that ends Nov. 30.
Oura Advisor is included with membership, and Oura calls it 'Oura's AI-powered health companion.' Oura says the ring tracks over 50 health metrics, and its app is available on iOS and Android. Oura's support page says the app needs iOS 16 or higher, or Android 11 or higher with Google Play services, and a device with Bluetooth 5.0. Oura marks the product as eligible for health savings account (HSA) and flexible spending account (FSA) funds.
Monthly billing at $5.99 comes to $71.88 a year, which is $1.89 more than the annual price of $69.99. Two years of the annual membership come to $139.98.
Pick the Oura Ring if you want an AI health companion and a membership is an acceptable recurring cost. If you do not want a membership, skip it, because Oura Advisor comes with membership.
How to Choose a Fitbit Alternative
Four facts narrow the options, so read them before the prices.
Google's Fitbit page says: 'Google promises to keep your data private. It's all for you, not for ads.' The same page says you can delete or export your health data anytime from your Google Health app. The other vendors' pages used here do not include an equivalent statement. For privacy questions beyond a single device, read protect your privacy online.
If you compare other Google products, see Google Photos alternatives or Google Search alternatives. For other kinds of products, start from all alternatives pages.
- Phone: the Apple Watch SE 3 needs an iPhone. The Oura app runs on iOS 16 or higher and Android 11 or higher.
- Subscription: the Polar Loop and Helio Strap list no required subscription. Withings+ is optional, Oura Advisor comes with an Oura membership, and Google Health Premium starts at $9.99 a month.
- Battery, longest first: up to 35 days for the ScanWatch Light, up to 14 days for the Bip 6, and up to 10 days for the Active 2 and the Helio Strap.
- Battery, shortest: 18 hours for the Apple Watch SE 3. The Charge 6 and Polar Loop pages do not state battery life.
- Safety features: Apple lists Crash Detection and Fall Detection. Fitbit lists Health Guardian alerts, including Irregular Rhythm Notifications, Loss of Pulse Detection and Breathing Emergency.
Who This Is Not For
If you want no recurring fee, do not pick the Fitbit Charge 6 expecting its paid features to be free. Fitbit says some workouts in the app require a membership, and Daily Readiness Score is available with Google Health Premium, which starts at $9.99 a month. For a device with no required subscription, the listed options are the Polar Loop and the Amazfit Helio Strap.
If you do not have an iPhone, do not pick the Apple Watch SE 3, because Apple says it needs one. If you do not want an Oura membership, do not pick the Oura Ring, because Oura Advisor is included with membership.
The Withings ScanWatch Light is not the right choice if you want the Withings+ scores and clinical expert care without paying for them. Those features sit in the optional subscription at $9.95 a month or $99.50 a year.
What Would Change Our Answer
A battery figure for the Fitbit Charge 6 would change the battery comparison. Fitbit does not state one, so the Charge 6 is not ranked on battery life here.
A published list price for the Oura Ring would change the cost comparison. Without it, the Oura row shows the sale discount and the membership, so the total cost of an Oura setup is not stated.
The Charge 6 price depends on a deal that ends 12/02. The listing shows $159.95 as the earlier price, so the saving is $30.00 while the deal runs.
A change to Google Health Premium pricing would change the subscription arithmetic. At the starting rate of $9.99 a month, two years come to $239.76, and a higher rate would raise that total.
A phone-compatibility statement from Withings, Polar or Amazfit would settle the phone question for those three vendors. Their pages used here state nothing on it.
When Fitbit Is the Better Fit
The Fitbit Charge 6 fits best when built-in GPS, an ECG app and Google's own app features matter. It is the only device here whose page mentions an ECG app, Google Maps turn-by-turn directions and Google Wallet tap to pay.
Among devices that state GPS, the Charge 6 at $129.95 is the lower-priced option. The Apple Watch SE 3 is listed from $229. Fitbit shows the Charge 6 at $129.95, down from $159.95, and the $30.00 difference runs until 12/02. Four payments of $32.49 total $129.96, one cent more than the single payment.
Fitbit says the Charge 6 includes 3 months of Google Health Premium. Three months at the $9.99 starting monthly rate comes to $29.97. Fitbit's page also says 'Get 3 months of personalized health coaching.'
Fitbit states the Charge 6 delivers 'up to 60% more accurate heart rate tracking during vigorous activities like high-intensity interval training (HIIT).' That is Fitbit's own claim.
The listed features also include more than 40 exercise modes, water resistance to 50 meters, SpO2 tracking, electrodermal activity (EDA) scans for stress response, Active Zone Minutes and a cardio fitness score. Google lists Health Coach as a 24/7 coach with adaptive fitness plans, sleep coaching and nutrition logging by photo.
Pick the Charge 6 if you want the listed GPS, ECG app, Google Maps and Google Wallet on one band, and you accept Google Health Premium pricing after the included months.
Verdict
Pick by constraint. If you need no required subscription, you have two options, the Polar Loop and the Amazfit Helio Strap. If you want the lowest hardware price, take the Amazfit Bip 6 at $79.99. If you need the longest battery, take the Withings ScanWatch Light at up to 35 days. If you need built-in GPS and an ECG app, take the Fitbit Charge 6.
Write down the one constraint you cannot change, then use it to narrow the Fitbit alternatives above to the devices that meet it.