Alternatives

iPhone Alternatives Compared on Price and Data Collection

Six alternatives, with the prices and data statements each product's own pages make.

By Jonathan WestLast updated 2026-11-20

iPhone alternatives include Light Phone III and Light Flip, Google Pixel with GrapheneOS, Fairphone, Punkt MC02 and MP02, and Murena phones. The iPhone lineup on Apple's own page includes iPhone Duo, iPhone 18 Pro, iPhone Air, iPhone 17, iPhone 17e and iPhone 16, plus iOS 27.

Prices, plan costs and data statements below come from each product's own site, read on 2026-11-20. Several of these products run their own operating system (OS), including LightOS, GrapheneOS, /e/OS and Apostrophy OS.

Artificial intelligence (AI) is the first difference. Apple says Apple Intelligence uses on-device processing for many requests and 'Private Cloud Compute' for more complex ones. Apple also says Apple Intelligence is aware of personal information without collecting it. The Apple features listed include Live Translation, grammar and spelling suggestions, writing help and Siri conversations.

The Google Store lists Gemini on Pixel as a feature, and Gemini is Google's AI assistant. Light, Fairphone, Punkt and Murena list no AI features on the product pages.

The privacy statements also differ in form. Apple says Safari blocks third-party cookies from tracking by default, and that Intelligent Tracking Prevention uses on-device machine learning. Murena says up to 12Mb of your data is collected every day without your consent. Murena also says /e/OS has no data scanning or location tracking 24/7.

Punkt says its MC02 includes a built-in secure virtual private network (VPN). The Punkt section below covers its other statements.

Fairphone and Punkt list dollar prices on their United States (US) store pages. Punkt's Swiss store lists the MP02 in Swiss francs, and Murena lists euros. Each section keeps the currency and billing unit that the site gives.

iPhone and Six Alternatives at a Glance

ProductBilling unit and entry priceBest fit
iPhoneiPhone 17 $929.00 for the 'Connect on your own later' option; a $30 connectivity discount requires activation with AT&T, T-Mobile or Verizon; iPhone 18 Pro lease example $34.99 a month for 24 months, excluding taxes and trade-in creditPick if you want the Apple Intelligence features and Safari that Apple's pages describe
Light PhoneLight Phone III $899 on the shop page; Light Flip $349 unlocked or from $39 a month on a two-year contract; Light Service $25 or $45 a month plus tax, billed on a 30-day periodPick if you want a phone that Light's FAQ says will never be able to browse the internet
Google Pixel with GrapheneOSPixel 10a from $549 on the Google Store, or $15.25 a month for 36 months; no price listed for GrapheneOSPick if you want GrapheneOS on a Pixel from Pixel 8 through Pixel 10a, the range its FAQ names
FairphoneFairphone (Gen. 6+) $649.99 on the US storePick if you want the listed 12 replaceable parts, five-year warranty and software support until 2033
Punkt MC02$499.00 on the US store pagePick if you want Apostrophy OS with the built-in secure VPN and the Swiss jurisdiction protections Punkt describes
MurenaMurena Pixel 7 refurbished €335.99; Murena Pixel 8 refurbished €351.99 to €397.99; Murena GS6 €369.99 to €449.99; Fairphone (Gen. 6) with /e/OS €599.99; Murena SHIFTphone 8 €774.99Pick if you want /e/OS on a refurbished Pixel, a Murena GS6 or SHIFTphone 8, or Fairphone hardware, priced in euros
Punkt MP02CHF 299.00 on Punkt's Swiss store, marked sold outPick if you want a 2.0-inch feature phone with calls, SMS and MMS, notes and Apostrophy OS, with no browser listed

Are you one of these vendors? Update your listing

How the iPhone Alternatives Differ

The six alternatives differ on four points: the software each phone runs, whether a browser is listed, how the price is billed, and what the product says about data. iPhone runs iOS, and Apple's privacy page describes Safari, which Apple says blocks third-party cookies from tracking by default.

Apple's privacy page also says Intelligent Tracking Prevention uses on-device machine learning. It says Private Browsing removes unique trackers from URLs and hides the internet protocol (IP) address from known trackers. Each alternative makes its own statements about data, and the sections below quote them as that product's claims.

Billing differs as well. iPhone 17 is listed at $929.00 for the 'Connect on your own later' option, and Apple's page also lists a lease example. Light Phone III is listed at $899, and Light Service plans are billed on a 30-day period. Murena lists euro prices, and Punkt lists the MP02 in Swiss francs.

Form factor is the last difference. Light Flip is a flip phone. The Punkt MP02 is a 2.0-inch feature phone. Light Phone III has a camera, and Light Phone II does not. For more options, see all alternatives pages and phones without AI.

Want to be added to this alternatives page?

Contact us

Light Phone III and Light Flip

Light Phone III is listed at $899 on Light's shop page. Light says Light Phone III has a camera. The FAQ says Light Phone III and Light Phone II both have Bluetooth and wifi and support wifi tethering. It also states that 'the device will never be able to browse the internet.'

Light Phone II has no camera, no internet browser, and no social media or apps. It is listed at $299 and marked sold out.

Light Flip is listed at $349 unlocked, or from $39 a month with a two-year Light Service plan contract, according to the FAQ. Light describes it as a flip form factor.

Light Service plans in the United States cost $25 plus tax a month for unlimited calls and messages with 1 gigabyte of data. The $45 plus tax plan adds unlimited data. Both are billed on a 30-day period, and a contract-free option exists. Light also has plans in Canada and the United Kingdom, and it provides a free subscriber identity module (SIM) in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom.

Light says its LightOS is 'built around intentionality & privacy' and works as a customizable menu of tools managed from a dashboard website. Light also says 'Light is an alternative to the tech monopolies.' Light's claim is that more than 100,000 people have gone light over 10 years. Light has a developer program.

Over two years, the arithmetic on listed figures runs as follows. Light Phone III at $899 with the $25 plan comes to $1,499 before tax (899 plus 24 times 25). With the $45 plan it comes to $1,979 before tax (899 plus 24 times 45). Light Flip at $349 with the $25 plan comes to $949 before tax (349 plus 24 times 25).

The Light Flip contract at $39 a month comes to $936 over 24 months (24 times 39). The FAQ lists that price as a two-year Light Service plan contract.

Light Phone III suits you if you want a camera and no browser. Light Phone II suits you if you want no camera and no apps, but the shop page marks it sold out. Against iPhone, both Light phones give up the Safari browser that Apple's privacy page describes. A Light Phone also requires an active compatible plan, so that plan cost applies to every figure above.

For more on these devices, see the Light Phone III review and Light Phone alternatives.

Google Pixel With GrapheneOS

GrapheneOS describes itself as a 'private and secure mobile operating system with Android app compatibility.' It says it is developed as a non-profit open source project. It was founded in 2014 and was formerly called CopperheadOS. GrapheneOS says it 'will never include either Google Play services or another implementation of Google services like microG.'

GrapheneOS also offers an optional sandboxed Google Play compatibility layer. It says its supported-device standards are met by Pixel 8 through Pixel 10a. Pixel 11 is outside the range its FAQ names.

The Google Store lists the Pixel 10a from $549, shown beside a $599 price with a $50 saving. It also lists $15.25 a month with 36-month financing, and 36 payments of $15.25 come to $549. GrapheneOS is not sold. The GrapheneOS site links to a donation page instead.

On the listed figures, the phone part of this option is $549, and GrapheneOS has no price. The Pixel 10a's $549 is $380.00 below the iPhone 17's listed $929.00 (929 minus 549), but the two products are different phones.

GrapheneOS describes permission toggles, including Network permission and Sensors permission. It also says it stops network time connections when network time is disabled.

The Google Store lists Gemini on Pixel as a feature, and Gemini is Google's AI assistant. The GrapheneOS statement about Google services covers its own software.

Pick this option if you want a Pixel phone running GrapheneOS, with Android app compatibility and the optional Google Play layer. Apple describes Apple Intelligence and Safari's tracking protections for iPhone. The GrapheneOS site mentions neither.

Fairphone

The Fairphone (Gen. 6+) is listed at $649.99 on Fairphone's US store, which ships to every state except Alaska and Hawaii. The Black Friday offer on that page includes a free screen protector and protective case.

Fairphone says the phone has a modular design with 12 replaceable parts, a five-year warranty and software support until 2033. The store page also mentions 'Privacy by design' and an app lounge of curated privacy-first apps.

Fairphone's European Union (EU) shop lists Android and /e/OS versions of both The Fairphone (Gen. 6+) and The Fairphone (Gen. 6). The EU shop also lists Keep Club and family-friendly smartphones.

Murena lists The Fairphone (Gen. 6+) with /e/OS at €649.99, down from €699.99. It lists The Fairphone (Gen. 6) with /e/OS at €599.99, down from €649.99. Those are euro prices from a different seller.

Against the iPhone 17's listed $929.00, the Fairphone (Gen. 6+) at $649.99 is $279.01 lower (929.00 minus 649.99). The two are different phones with different cameras, batteries and warranties.

Pick the Fairphone if you want the listed replaceable parts and five-year warranty, or if you want /e/OS on the same hardware. Its listed software support ends in 2033.

Punkt MC02 and MP02

Punkt says the MC02 is a secure fifth-generation (5G) smartphone designed in Switzerland. Punkt's US store page lists it at $499.00.

The phone runs Apostrophy OS, which Punkt says is based on the Android Open Source Project (AOSP) version 13. Punkt says the phone has a built-in secure VPN, and that email, calendar, contacts, notes, storage and VPN are protected within Swiss jurisdiction.

Punkt also says the phone is 'free from advertising-driven data collection.' It lists the Vanadium Browser as part of the Apostrophy subscription, included for 12 months with the MC02. It also describes a tool that lets you install Android apps from Google Play on Apostrophy.

The listed specifications are a 6.67-inch display at 1080 by 2400 resolution, 128-gigabyte storage, a MediaTek Dimensity 900 chip and a weight of 230 grams.

At $499.00, the MC02 is $430.00 below the iPhone 17's listed $929.00 (929 minus 499). The MC02 page lists no AI feature.

Punkt also sells the MP02, a fourth-generation (4G) minimalist phone. Punkt's Swiss store lists it at CHF 299.00 and marks it sold out. The listed functions are calls, SMS and MMS, contacts, notes, clock, calculator, calendar and hotspot, and the page names no browser.

The MP02 has a 2.0-inch display at 320 by 240 resolution, 2 gigabytes of RAM, 16 gigabytes of storage, a 1,280 milliampere-hour battery and a weight of 100 grams. It runs Apostrophy OS (APHY 1.3), and the specifications say 'No further Android/Vendor updates planned.' Punkt lists a Swiss-franc price only, so no dollar total is possible.

Pick the MC02 if you want an Android-based system with a built-in VPN and the Swiss jurisdiction statement. Punkt's statements cover email, calendar, contacts, notes, storage and VPN. Apple's statements cover Safari and Private Browsing, so the two sets protect different things.

Murena

Murena sells deGoogled phones running /e/OS, which it describes as 'open source, pro-privacy and fully degoogled.' Murena also sells Workspace cloud services and accessories. Its smartphone page lists prices in euros only.

Murena lists the Fairphone (Gen. 6+) with /e/OS at €649.99, which is €50.00 below its original €699.99. It lists the Fairphone (Gen. 6) with /e/OS at €599.99, down from €649.99. Those two are Fairphone hardware, so they appear in the Fairphone section too.

Murena's own-name devices include a refurbished Pixel 7 at €335.99 and a refurbished Pixel 8 from €351.99 to €397.99. They also include the GS6 and GS6 PRO from €369.99 to €449.99 and the SHIFTphone 8 at €774.99. Murena also lists the HIROH Phone powered by Murena at €1199.00.

Murena says 'Up to 12Mb of your data is collected every day without your consent.' It also says /e/OS has 'no data scanning or location tracking 24/7.' It adds that most favourite apps contain trackers harvesting your location and activities.

The gap between Murena's lowest own-name price, the refurbished Pixel 7 at €335.99, and the SHIFTphone 8 at €774.99 is €439.00 (774.99 minus 335.99). Murena's site lists no US dollar price, so there is no dollar figure for Murena.

Pick Murena if you want /e/OS on a refurbished Pixel, a Murena GS6 or SHIFTphone 8, or Fairphone hardware, with prices in euros. Murena's pages describe /e/OS, and Apple's pages describe Safari and Private Browsing on iPhone.

How to Choose an iPhone Alternative

Start with the requirement you cannot give up, because the six alternatives split on it. Light Phone III and Light Phone II cannot browse the internet, according to Light's FAQ. GrapheneOS and Punkt's Apostrophy OS describe Android-based software, and Murena and Fairphone sell /e/OS versions.

Work through these five points in order:

  • Browser: Light's FAQ says Light Phone III and Light Phone II will never be able to browse the internet. Punkt lists the Vanadium Browser for the MC02 and names no browser for the MP02. Apple describes Safari on iPhone.
  • Google services: GrapheneOS says it never includes Google Play services or microG, and Murena says /e/OS is fully degoogled.
  • AI features: Apple lists Apple Intelligence on iPhone, and the Google Store lists Gemini on Pixel. Light, Fairphone, Punkt and Murena list no AI features.
  • Billing: the device price, the monthly plan price and the currency differ across these sites, so put the numbers in one unit before adding them.
  • Data statements: Apple, Murena and Punkt each make their own statements, and the sections above quote them as those products' claims.

Who This Is Not For

The Light phones do not fit you if you need a browser on the phone, because Light's FAQ says the device will never be able to browse the internet. Light Phone II also has no camera and no apps, so if you want a camera, look at Light Phone III. For browsers on other phones, see all alternatives pages.

The Punkt MP02 does not fit you if you need apps, because its listed functions are calls, messages, contacts, notes and utilities. It is also marked sold out, and Punkt lists it in Swiss francs only.

The Pixel with GrapheneOS option does not fit you if you need Google Play services by default. GrapheneOS says it never includes them and offers an optional sandboxed compatibility layer. Murena's prices are in euros, so you get no dollar price from its site.

If you want the Apple Intelligence features Apple lists, none of these alternatives list them. Those features include Live Translation, grammar and spelling suggestions, writing help and Siri conversations. For more minimal phones, see minimal phone alternatives.

What Would Change Our Answer

A published dollar price for the Punkt MP02 or for Murena's phones would put those options on the same basis as the others. A listed price for GrapheneOS would complete the Pixel option's price.

If Light changed its FAQ statement that the device 'will never be able to browse the internet,' the Light Phone III answer for anyone who needs a browser would change. A new Light Service plan or price change would also change the two-year totals, which are arithmetic on the listed figures.

A published carrier plan price for the iPhone would allow a monthly total for iPhone. Apple's iPhone page lists the phone prices and the lease example, but no carrier plan price.

If GrapheneOS added Pixel 11 to the supported range its FAQ names, the Pixel option would cover that model. If an alternative's site listed AI features, the AI comparison in the introduction would change.

When iPhone Is the Better Fit

iPhone is the better fit when the listed Apple features are the requirement. Apple describes Apple Intelligence, Safari's third-party cookie blocking, Intelligent Tracking Prevention and Private Browsing. None of the alternatives list a browser with those protections.

iPhone is also the only option here with a listed lease. Apple's iPhone page lists a lease example for the iPhone 18 Pro, and none of the alternatives list a lease.

Apple says 'no one else can access your data, not even Apple' for its privacy protections. That is Apple's own statement.

Verdict

For a full smartphone without Google services, Pixel with GrapheneOS starts from the listed Pixel 10a price of $549 with no GrapheneOS price, and Murena sells /e/OS phones in euros. Fairphone at $649.99 and Punkt MC02 at $499.00 cover repairable and Swiss-designed hardware. The Punkt MP02 covers basic calls and texts at CHF 299.00.

The iPhone 17 is listed at $929.00 for the 'Connect on your own later' option. The Google Store lists Gemini on Pixel, and the other alternatives list no AI feature.

Write down the one requirement you cannot give up, find the matching row in the table, and total the two-year cost in one currency to pick among these iPhone alternatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the cheapest iPhone alternative?
Light Flip is the lowest listed dollar price at $349 unlocked. Punkt MC02 is next at $499.00. Murena lists euro prices, starting at €335.99 for a refurbished Pixel 7. The Punkt MP02 lists CHF 299.00.
Which iPhone alternatives have no browser?
Light Phone III and Light Phone II cannot browse the internet, according to Light's FAQ, which says the device will never be able to browse the internet. The Punkt MP02 page lists calls, messages, contacts, notes and utilities and names no browser. The Punkt MC02 lists the Vanadium Browser.
Do any of these phones run without Google services?
GrapheneOS says it never includes Google Play services or another implementation of Google services like microG, though it offers an optional sandboxed Google Play compatibility layer. Murena describes /e/OS as fully degoogled, and Fairphone's EU shop lists /e/OS versions of two Fairphone models.
Does a Light Phone need a plan?
Yes. Light says a Light Phone requires an active compatible plan. Light Service plans in the United States cost $25 plus tax or $45 plus tax a month. Light says it provides a free SIM in the United States, Canada and the United Kingdom.
Which iPhone alternatives list AI features?
Apple lists Apple Intelligence on iPhone, and the Google Store lists Gemini on Pixel. Light, Fairphone, Punkt and Murena list no AI features.